How Do the Probate Courts Handle Beneficiary Disputes?

After a loved one passes away, you may know that they drafted a will during their lifetime and that this document will settle everything. You may then be surprised to learn that the same document is now creating many questions and has become a source of tension for you and other loved ones. This can lead to beneficiary disputes and they are much more common than people think and as such, the probate courts in Florida follow a legal framework to address them. Below, our New Port Richey probate lawyer explains in further detail.
What Grounds Can Beneficiaries Use to Challenge an Estate?
When a dispute arises between beneficiaries, there are a number of common grounds they may use to challenge the estate. These include:
- The person who drafted the will was under undue influence
- The person who wrote the will lacked the testamentary capacity to do so
- The personal representative mismanaged the estate or provided improper accounting
- There are conflicts of interests in how the assets in the estate are being managed
- The will was not executed according to the formal requirements in Florida
These concerns are taken very seriously under Florida law. The personal representative of the estate owes the same fiduciary duty to the estate’s beneficiaries that a trustee owes to the beneficiaries of a trust. If a personal representative breaches that duty, they can be found personally liable for paying damages caused by the breach.
How are Beneficiary Disputes Handled by the Probate Courts?
After a dispute is filed with the probate court, a judge will review the evidence in the same way they would in any civil lawsuit. The judge may then hear testimony regarding the dispute, such as how a will was created, require the personal representative to provide a full accounting, and determine whether there is merit to a beneficiary’s objection.
If damages have been incurred, the court has many remedies available. They may order restitution to the estate, remove the personal representative, or award attorney’s fees to the harmed party. The goal of the probate courts is always to ensure the property in an estate is distributed the way the deceased individual, and the law, intended.
Fortunately, not all disputes end up in probate court. Beneficiaries and other parties may negotiate outside of the courtroom and reach an agreeable solution among themselves. When this is not possible, the matter may have to be taken before a judge.
Our Probate Lawyer in New Port Richey Can Address Your Concerns
If you are worried that your loved one’s estate is not being managed properly, that their will was manipulated or created under false pretenses, or you are dealing with another dispute or concern, our New Port Richey probate lawyer can help. At Messina Law Group, P.A., our experienced attorney can advise you of your rights and help you resolve your dispute so the process is as easy as possible for you. Call us today at (813) 492-7798 or fill out our online form to schedule a consultation with our experienced attorney.
Source:
leg.state.fl.us/statutes/index.cfm?App_mode=Display_Statute&URL=0700-0799/0733/0733ContentsIndex.html
